Baked to order in Kissimmee, Florida

Custom cakes and sweet treats for every yay.

Celebration-worthy cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and dipped treats made with care, creativity, and a little extra sweetness.

Baked to orderMade for your date and celebration
Personal touchesCustom colors, themes, and details
Kissimmee pickupDelivery available by request

A little about the baker

Delicious sweets with a big celebration feeling

StephiesSugarShop is Stephie’s home cottage bakery in Kissimmee, Florida. Every order is made with love, care, and creativity—whether it’s a custom centerpiece cake or a box of classic cookies.

The goal is simple: thoughtful sweets, approachable pricing, and something special for the moments worth celebrating.

Let’s make your sugary dreams a reality.

Limited-time menu

Thanksgiving Cozy Special Menu

Custom sweets to bring your seasonal gatherings some extra sweetness this fall!

Now booking Thanksgiving orders!
Stephie's Sugar Shop Thanksgiving Cozy Special Menu flyer: Mini Fall Treat Box $15, Classic Fall Treat Box $30, Deluxe Fall Treat Box $50, Thanksgiving Cupcakes 6 for $15 or 12 for $28, and Thanksgiving Apple Pie $22, baked per order, 9-inch round.

How ordering works

From idea to “oh my gosh.”

Choose treats + date

Share your item, flavor, theme, and date. Custom cakes need 1–2 weeks’ notice; simpler treats may be available with a few days’ notice.

Book with 50%

Once your details and price are confirmed, a 50% deposit reserves your date.

Pick up & celebrate

Pick up your order in Kissimmee. Delivery may be available by request.

Kind words

Made for happy moments.

★★★★★
“I ordered a protein Oreo cake for my mom's "500 subscribers" on YouTube video and it was a HIT. Everyone looooved it and couldn't even tell there was protein it. ❤️”
Diamond Ross November 8, 2026
★★★★★
“She is so caring and the food was amazing! She made my cupcake dreams come true!”
Julie Handlin October 16, 2026
★★★★★
“Stephanie did amazing on my pencil pretzels as well as my meet the teacher smiley face Oreos. The kids loved them!”
Andrea Barber-Campos
★★★★★
“Stephanie provides great service and amazing tasting treats. I will be ordering again.”
Avery Whaley
★★★★★
“I ordered from Stephie's Sugar Shop for my kid's elementary graduation treats we all loved them! We ordered chocolate covered pretzels, chocolate covered Oreos, and cake pops. I would definitely order from her again!”
Jordan Kmetz
★★★★★
“Stephanie did an amazing job making the sweet treats for Mother's Day gifts!! The treats came in cute packaging and were exactly what I wanted!!”
abbie guile
★★★★★
“I have ordered from this business a few times already, and everything I have bought has been absolutely delicious and adorable to look at! I just purchased a “Spooky Box” for my grandkids. They loved it! It was their snack for our kickoff to decorating for Halloween. Stephanie does such a beautiful job on all of her baked goods. I will be ordering from her over and over again. Thank you so much for an awesome product!”
Kimberly Hughes

Enjoyed your order?

Your review helps a small local bakery get discovered—and helps the next customer order with confidence.

Leave a Google review

Order inquiry

Tell me what you’re celebrating.

Build a clear request with all the details Stephie needs, then email it directly or DM @StephiesSugarShop to order.

This form prepares a request only; your date is not booked until details, price, and deposit are confirmed.

Your order request


            
Email Stephie

Good to know

Frequently asked questions.

How far ahead should I order?

Custom cakes need 1–2 weeks’ notice. Simpler treats may be available with a few days’ notice. Availability depends on the date and order details.

How do I reserve my date?

After the order details and total are confirmed, a 50% deposit is required to book your date.

Is pickup or delivery available?

Orders are available for pickup in Kissimmee, Florida. Delivery may be available by request.

Can I request a custom design?

Yes. Share your theme, colors, inspiration, wording, and the date you need it. Final pricing depends on design and detail.

What should I know about allergens?

Products are made in a home kitchen. Menu items may contain or come into contact with milk, eggs, wheat, soy, peanuts, tree nuts, and sesame. Peanut butter cookies are offered. Please share allergy concerns before ordering.